Until this very moment I wasn’t sure if I was going to pick Blue October’s Foiled or History for Sale. Both albums are superb and I suppose, since History for Sale came first, I’ll go with it. I simply can’t decide which one had a bigger impact on me. (And yes, I’m feeling a torn for not choosing Foiled…seriously, Hate Me is a masterpiece of a song).

Blue came to my notice when I my friend gave me a cd with a bunch of songs of their songs. All my friends were talking about them and I wanted to know what the deal was. It was love at first listen.

I think Blue is probably one of the most under-appreciated bands out there. I have a hard time wrapping my head around why they are played ALL THE TIME on the radio. Maybe due to the brutal honesty about mental health, suicide and addiction Justin Fustenfeld writes about? I don’t know, but whatever the reason, its shameful. Justin lyrics are often dark, but are some of the most poetic words spoken. Yet, his lyrics aren’t lofty, but like a personal conversation he’s having with the listener. The music is generally on the heavier side of rock, catchy and often cheerful, creating an interesting dynamic with the often darker lyrics.

But not every song is dark on History for Sale. Calling You was written by Justin for his girlfriend. It a straightforward and beautiful song about finding love.

If you ever get a chance to see Blue live. Go. I saw them once at Milwaukee’s Summerfest. Justin had broken his leg and performed the entire 2 hours alternating between crutches and sitting on a stool, but nothing of the energy was missing. It was one of the best shows I have ever seen.